Feedback, Q&A

Hey hey,

I'm in the process of coming up with Rank Challenges for my pack of Cliaths advancing to Fostern in my 90's Detroit setting. The challenges will be occurring during the Rite of the Long Vigil at the packs own Caern (The Caern of the Cleansing Mother).

I am lucky enough to have 5 players filling each Auspice and I have some ideas I'll place below but I just wanted to see what you guys made of them.

• Haelan Lionheart (Alpha, Child of Gaia Galliard): Learn the stories behind the Deed names of Holte Hunt-Runner (Talesinger at the Caern) and Tears-at-Moonrise (Visiting Ragabash), without asking them directly and regale them at the Moot. 

• Lucius Pride of Falcon (Silver Fang Philodox): Settle an adjudication between Friend of the Fallen & Prowls the Borders (two visiting Garou), regarding who will mate with one of the kinfolk Lyka Rolleston. 

• Milton Gaia's Fist (Fianna Ahroun): Plan a defence of the heart of the Caern with the Motown Runners from a selected pack of Garou. 

• Inaya Shadowstalker (Silent Strider Theurge): Convince Lucius to learn a Bone Gnawer Gift from a visiting member of the tribe.

• Billie Mouth of Gaia (Black Fury Ragabash): Find Holte Hunt Runners eye.

I was just curious on your guys thoughts. Am I going too off piece here? I am particularly cautious about the challenge for Inaya as Lucius is quite anti Bone Gnawer and I don't want to punish a player for another players decisions.